Skip to content

Form 5472 common mistakes: the 9 errors that lead to the $25,000 penalty

The penalty is the same whether you did not file or filed a form the IRS considers substantially incomplete. Most errors are small, and all of them are avoidable.

Short answer

The IRS charges $25,000 to a company that does not file Form 5472 on time, and it treats a substantially incomplete form as not filed. If the failure continues more than 90 days after the IRS notifies you, another $25,000 is added. The most common errors are sending it to the wrong place, leaving out the owner's contributions and withdrawals, and skipping the pro forma Form 1120.

For the full picture, read our complete Form 5472 guide for foreign-owned LLCs; to have it prepared and filed for you, see our Form 5472 filing service.

Not sure how this applies to your numbers or deadlines? Review your case in a free 30-minute consultation with our Form 5472 filing service.

Book your free consultation
In this guide (6)
  1. The 9 most common mistakes
  2. What does "substantially incomplete" mean?
  3. How much can the penalty add up to?
  4. What records do I have to keep?
  5. Can the penalty be removed?
  6. How we can help

The 9 most common mistakes

  1. Not filing because the LLC had no income. The form reports transactions with the owner, not income. See do I need to file Form 5472.
  2. Sending Form 5472 alone. A foreign-owned LLC attaches it to a pro forma Form 1120.
  3. Trying to e-file, or mailing it to the regular Form 1120 address. It goes by fax to 855-887-7737 or by mail to the IRS unit in Ogden, Utah. See how to send it.
  4. Leaving out contributions and withdrawals. Money the owner puts in or takes out is reportable and goes on the attached statement. See reportable transactions.
  5. Forgetting formation costs. The state fee or registered agent paid by the owner personally is reportable in the first year.
  6. Leaving the related party section blank because the owner already appears earlier on the form. The IRS asks for it again.
  7. Filing without an EIN or with the wrong one. The LLC needs its own EIN before it files.
  8. Missing the deadline when the extension was available. Form 7004 gives six more months if it is sent on time. See due date and extension.
  9. Keeping no proof. Without the fax report or the mail receipt, you cannot show that you filed on time.

What does "substantially incomplete" mean?

The instructions say that filing a substantially incomplete Form 5472 is a failure to file. They do not give a list, so the safe reading is practical: every part that applies to you must be answered, the related party must be identified, and the transactions that happened must be reported with their amounts. A form with the owner's details but no transactions, when money did move, is the typical case.

How much can the penalty add up to?

  • $25,000 for each year not filed, or filed late or substantially incomplete.
  • Another $25,000 if the failure continues more than 90 days after the IRS notifies you, and again for each further 30 days.
  • The same penalty applies for not keeping the required records.
  • In a group, each company is a separate filer with its own penalty.

What records do I have to keep?

Records that show your transactions with related parties were reported correctly: bank statements, proof of transfers between you and the LLC, receipts for costs paid by the owner, loan agreements and invoices between related companies. Keep them with your copy of each year's filing.

Can the penalty be removed?

The IRS can remove it when you show reasonable cause, and the request is stronger when the missing forms are filed before the IRS asks for them. See the Form 5472 penalty and late filing.

How we can help

Our Enrolled Agent reviews forms that were already filed, tells you whether they hold up and corrects or files what is missing, including prior years. The first 30-minute consultation is free. See our Form 5472 filing service.

File Form 5472 right the first time.

We review your transactions, prepare Form 5472 with the pro forma 1120 and file it on time, including any missed years.

  • Bring to the call: The LLC's formation documents and EIN letter, the company's bank statements for the year, and what you put in or took out.
  • The call: 30 minutes by Google Meet with our team, free, in English or Spanish.
  • What you get: Which forms apply to you and their exact deadlines, plus a written proposal with the fee before you pay anything.

Want us to file it for you? See our Form 5472 filing service.

Pick a day and time Ask on WhatsApp
Times are shown in your own time zone.

Frequently asked questions

What are the most common Form 5472 mistakes?

Not filing because the LLC had no income, sending Form 5472 without the pro forma Form 1120, sending it to the wrong address or trying to e-file, and leaving out the owner's contributions, withdrawals and formation costs.

What does "substantially incomplete" mean for Form 5472?

The IRS treats a substantially incomplete Form 5472 as a failure to file, with the same $25,000 penalty. In practice, every part that applies must be answered and the transactions that happened must be reported.

Is there a penalty for not keeping Form 5472 records?

Yes. The $25,000 penalty also applies to a company that fails to keep the records required for its transactions with related parties.

Official sources

Related guides

This article is general information about U.S. federal tax rules as of October 2026. It is not advice for your specific situation. Rules and amounts change; confirm how they apply to you before acting. Our representation before the IRS is governed by U.S. Treasury Department Circular 230.

Speak with an Enrolled Agent before your next deadline.

Choose how you'd like to reach us. Free 30-minute initial consultation, with no obligation.

  • No cost or obligation. You pay nothing until you approve a written proposal.
  • Concrete answers. By the end of the consultation you will know what you need to file and by when.
  • Timely attention. We contact you within one business day, in English or Spanish.
ADTAX Advisor

Tax firm registered in Orlando, Florida, serving clients across the United States and abroad, including Orlando and Central Florida.

ADTAX Advisor is not affiliated with the IRS or any government agency.

Tax representation before the IRS is governed by U.S. Treasury Department Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10). Information on this website is educational and does not constitute individualized tax or legal advice.

© 2026 ADTAX Advisor. All rights reserved.